Conclusion Based on Article Origin ☀
“Israel is an unnatural state. It was created by terror that was accommodated by craven British and US “diplomacy”. Israel exists for one reason only: the US government provides the money, weapons, and diplomatic protection. Any other government that murdered thousands of civilians in other countries, as Israel does routinely in Lebanon, Gaza, and the West Bank, would have its entire government and military on trial before the War Crimes Tribunal at the Hague. Israelis have no worst enemy than their own government. Every time the rest of the world tries to hold the Israeli government accountable for its crimes, the US vetoes the UN resolution. America has become the enabler of the Zionist-hijacked Israeli government. And the Israeli government knows it. Israeli government leaders have publicly bragged for decades about their control over the US government.” — Paul Craig Roberts1. Posting things from VDARE.com? Really?
2. If Israel is an unnatural state, so are a shit ton of other countries that were carved out of former colonies. I don’t think that ethnic identity is a good basis for a stable country, and I agree that the Israeli government is Israel’s own worst enemy but is the way it was formed really such an anomaly? And if it is, weren’t there extraordinary circumstances surrounding its establishment? (It’s been years since I studied post-colonial histories of any country, so maybe I’m wrong!)
See genetic fallacy.
It’s not the first time I’ve received correspondence criticizing or questioning a published reference of a link to a Paul Craig Roberts column on VDARE.com.
While, I certainly do not share the philosophy (at least >99% positive of this) of VDARE.com and its anti-immigration (even conceding that a good bit of it is based in hate and/or racism), in the case of this columnist, Paul Craig Roberts, I believe its just a matter of reposting a past mainstream credentialed conservative and his perspective. Roberts served as assistant treasury secretary under President Reagan and also possesses first hand experience of working as a Wall Street Journal editor, which indeed is quite relevant in this polemic.
And as I’ve stated previously, not everything posted here I am in l lock-step agreement with. On occasion, you may even peruse an item completely counter to my view at that point in time, but worthy for some nugget(s). Honestly, there is not much in the political philosophy of Roberts adheres to that I concur with. However, his assessment of empire and global economics have definitely been more prescient than the parade of mainstream neoliberal economists and corporate shills who’ve wrecked America.
Finally, I wish to reiterate a gripe with the Tumblr “dialogue” in that I am befuddled in how to respond to dashboard/note replies. I wished to respond to kohenari:
The original post from which this quote is drawn advocates removing Jews from ME: “I want it moved or reformed. Bring the small number of Israelis to America before there is a nuclear war over the fact that they are where they should not be.”
Here is the context of that cite:
I am a critic of Israel’s heartless policy toward the Palestinians, but I do not want Israel destroyed. As I wrote in 2002—a column that as Taranto notes is archived only at VDARE.COM—I want it moved or reformed. Bring the small number of Israelis to America before there is a nuclear war over the fact that they are where they should not be. [VDARE.COM note: for a different suggestion, see here].To try to claim a land and dispossess its people on the basis of a spurious two thousand year year old deed is an audacious act of conquest and dispossession.My proposal to relocate Israelis in the US is rhetorical. But why not insist that the Israelis, who are heavily dependent on US largess, reform? Why should Americans support an apartheid racist state that denies citizenship to the rightful inhabitants? What kind of morality, if any, does the Wall Street Journal editorial page represent when it defends Israelis who force Palestinians into ever-shrinking ghettos, deprived of water, food, medical care and schools? Why must Palestinians live in dread of Israeli bulldozers arriving to flatten their homes in order to create space for Zionist“settlers”.
For the record, I do not agree with this ridiculous rhetorical suggestion that Israel be “moved”. But I do think there are legitimate questions of how the government of Israel is conducting its relations with displaced Palestinians.


