AZspot AZspot

blue bits. red rocks.
Monday 9 July 2012
Rand and Ron Paul denounce net neutrality and the public domain

Rand and Ron Paul have penned an Internet Freedom manifesto that is pretty terrible. It pans the idea of net neutrality, arguing that the phone companies who receive gigantic government handouts in the form of cheap (or free) rights of ways and hold natural monopolies over our connectivity should be able to use that government largesse to run a protection racket in which any website that doesn’t pay for “premium carriage” will be slowed down when you or I try to visit them. They also denounce the public domain as a collectivist plot, and argue that government monopolies over knowledge should be extended, and that tax-dollars should be used to enforce them. TechDirt’s Mike Masnick has some choice words for the Pauls:

To them, any support of a neutral internet must be about “coercive state actions” and “collective rule” over “privately owned broadband high-speed infrastructure.” This makes me curious if the Pauls spoke out against the billions and billions in subsidies and rights of way grants that the government provided the telcos and cable providers to build their networks. Once again, I am against regulating net neutrality — because it’s obvious that the telcos will control that process and the regulations will favor them against the public — but pretending that broadband infrastructure is really “privately owned” when so much of it involved tax-payer-funded subsidies and rights of way is being in denial.

Then there’s the following, where they claim that these evil “collectivists” want to limit “private property rights on the internet” and are saying that “what is considered to be in the public domain should be greatly expanded.” Considering the Pauls were both instrumental in the fight against SOPA and PIPA, you would think that the two of them understood how copyright law is massively abused and how beneficial the public domain is. But apparently not. To them it’s all part of this “collectivist” plot. Earth to the Pauls: copyright is a massive government-granted monopoly privilege. That’s the kind of thing we thought you were against, not for. In this document, you seem to be arguing for one of the largest programs in the world of a centralized government handing out private monopoly privileges.

40 notes

  1. veruca-assault reblogged this from azspot
  2. theamericanbear reblogged this from azspot
  3. questionall reblogged this from azspot
  4. raochelle reblogged this from robotbears
  5. elgin-marbles reblogged this from robotbears
  6. robotbears reblogged this from azspot
  7. whiskeyandcigarettes reblogged this from shorterexcerpts
  8. thetreesareenergy reblogged this from shorterexcerpts
  9. jolly-dolly reblogged this from azspot and added:
    The Pauls - hereditary dickbags.
  10. theadamglass reblogged this from azspot
  11. shorterexcerpts reblogged this from azspot
  12. azspot posted this

A GNT creation ©2007–2013