AZspot AZspot

blue bits. red rocks.
Friday 13 November 2009
Hiding Hiroshima

After the second bomb dropped, a Japanese company sent a film crew to document what was happening in the cities – the leveled ground, the dying. They were the only ones filming. If you were an American, you hadn’t seen a thing but a mushroom cloud. The news told you that we’d bombed the Japanese, and why we did it – ostensibly, to end the war.

But the U.S. military stepped in and banned the filming, taking what the Japanese had already recorded. Later, the military selected one of its own to head up a camera crew, Lt. Daniel McGovern, and document this campaign in Japan. They recorded every horror they saw.

What happened to that film, the footage we’d sent soldiers and civilians in to radiation-blasted cities to capture? The government suppressed every bit of film that documented the effects of the bombings and attempted to do the same with photographs. The Japanese film disappeared for more than 20 years. The footage McGovern’s crews recorded vanished for more than 30. We labeled it secret and hid it away.

It’s easy enough to come up with reasons why the government would have wanted to suppress the films — if people saw the sort of devastation atomic bombs could cause, they might not be so quick to support the use of nuclear weapons.

Such well-kept government secrets only reinforce the importance of journalism, even in the age of user-generated content. And we can thank people like McGovern and his crew and the Japanese newsreel team for their bravery.

Today, we have a parallel, of course. How many photos have you seen of dead soldiers in Afghanistan? How many photos of soldiers’ coffins?

The argument for suppressing the photos is that it’s unpatriotic to publish them and pushes a pacifist agenda. It can also be incredibly painful for families to see their dead loved ones in the news.

The argument against is that unless we see what we’re sacrificing, we don’t understand the cost of what we’re engaged in, or the courage it takes to get it done.

25 notes

  1. moonface reblogged this from soupsoup
  2. nikorette reblogged this from azspot
  3. continuum reblogged this from azspot
  4. corco reblogged this from erickd and added:
    Interesting views here
  5. ledgergermane reblogged this from azspot and added:
    Hiding Hiroshima…and everything else.
  6. erickd reblogged this from azspot
  7. takaakik reblogged this from suddenly
  8. abcsoupdot reblogged this from azspot and added:
    After the second bomb dropped, a Japanese company sent a film crew to document what was happening in the cities – the...
  9. soupsoup reblogged this from azspot
  10. suddenly reblogged this from gilmoure
  11. gilmoure reblogged this from azspot
  12. azspot posted this

A GNT creation ©2007–2012